Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma

By Ernest Gellner

Ernest Gellner (1925-1995) has been defined as "one of the final nice crucial eu polymath intellectuals." during this, his final e-book, he throws new gentle on key figures of the 20th century: the thinker Wittgenstein, and Malinowski, founding father of sleek British social anthropology. Gellner indicates how the idea of either males grew from a standard heritage of assumptions approximately human nature, society, and language. He ties jointly subject matters that preoccupied him, epitomizing his trust that philosophy--far from "leaving every thing because it is"--is approximately very important ancient, social and private matters.

Show description

Preview of Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma PDF

Best Anthropology books

Among the Cannibals: Adventures on the Trail of Man’s Darkest Ritual

It is the stuff of nightmares, the darkish suggestion for literature and movie. yet astonishingly, cannibalism does exist, and in one of the Cannibals shuttle author Paul Raffaele trips to the a long way corners of the globe to find individuals during this mysterious and irritating perform. From an vague New Guinea river village, the place Raffaele went looking for one of many final practising cannibal cultures in the world; to India, the place the Aghori sect nonetheless ritualistically devour their lifeless; to North the USA, the place facts exists that the Aztecs ate sacrificed sufferers; to Tonga, the place the descendants of fierce warriors nonetheless take into accout how their predecessors preyed upon their foes; and to Uganda, the place the unlucky sufferers of the Lord's Resistance military fight to reenter a society from which they've been violently torn, Raffaele brings this baffling cultural ritual to mild in a mix of Indiana Jones-type event and gonzo journalism.

The World Until Yesterday: What Can We Learn from Traditional Societies?

The bestselling writer of cave in and weapons, Germs and metal surveys the heritage of human societies to reply to the query: What do we research from conventional societies which can make the area a greater position for we all? so much folks take with no consideration the gains of our glossy society, from air trip and telecommunications to literacy and weight problems.

War Before Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage

The parable of the peace-loving "noble savage" is chronic and pernicious. certainly, for the final fifty years, most well-liked and scholarly works have agreed that prehistoric struggle used to be infrequent, risk free, unimportant, and, like smallpox, a ailment of civilized societies by myself. Prehistoric struggle, in accordance with this view, used to be little greater than a ritualized online game, the place casualties have been restricted and the results of aggression rather light.

Additional info for Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma

Show sample text content

Their inversion then turns into the beautiful new illumination, which, once more, settles every thing. Language isn't what I had proposal it used to be eighty five 86 Wittgenstein (tedious brass rubbings of world-atoms and their random summation ± if ever there's a recipe for hell, that has to be it): it really is ± oh bliss ± an access price tag to a closed neighborhood! Even higher ± it's not only a permission, it constitutes a duty to affix it! neighborhood isn't really a droit de seigneur, it's a devoir de seigneur! it's not absolutely transparent even if, in Wittgenstein's personal brain, it was once technical defects within the elaboration of his prior philosophy that condemned it or extra basic positive aspects inherent within the style as such. both means, while in any case he grew to become confident that his previous imaginative and prescient didn't paintings, a tacit premise was once to be had which guaranteed him that if his preliminary choice didn't paintings, then a definite different one has to be legitimate. there have been yet ideas on the earth. the idea used to be now not altogether tacit, for (as famous above) he truly articulated it in dialog with Norman Malcolm. So his later philosophy exempli®es, once more in a really exaggerated model verging on parody, a kind of natural romanticism. Positivistic individualism and romantic communalism among them exhaust the choices open to the human spirit: that a lot is apparent and past all query. actually, this isn't so: however it used to be shut adequate to the reality approximately Habsburg Vienna. Why may still the tacit premise appear so cogent? faraway from being cogent, it's not remotely real. however it was once deeply inscribed into the genuine lifestyles scenario of the voters, exceptionally of the intellectuals, of the Habsburg Empire in its terminal interval. good points which pervade the lifestyles scenario of someone can and sometimes do collect the cogency of a surely impossible to resist logical compulsion . . . The declare made here's that this is often what did take place to Wittgenstein, and this on my own explains his curious and passionate improvement. different extra hypotheses, adduced through Janik and Toulmin and others, are rather redundant, and probably produce other defects. All one relatively wishes is the `two ideas' assumption and the removing, at the foundation of no matter what concerns, of 1 of them. The removing in Wittgenstein's brain is easily documented in his later paintings: it constitutes its dominant topic. the fitting concerns which excluded the ®rst choice are much less transparent, however it doesn't actually matter greatly. We may well speculate approximately his causes for wishing to flee the solitary mobile to which his early place con®ned him: it truly is not going that we will ever have direct facts in this element, for it really is inconceivable that he used to be aware of it. He didn't imagine in socio-historical phrases, and used to be not going to assert to himself ± I desire to break out the alienation of rootless cosmopolitan intellectuals in a global the place the dominant values are nationalist and populist, and my new idea of language either damns the universalist/individualist thought of language, and really proves that Janik and Toulmin: a critique 87 someone who speaks in any respect, is immediately a member of a neighborhood: `Hurrah!

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.68 of 5 – based on 13 votes